Our branches send stock to each other most days. When a branch is short of something another one has plenty of, the sending branch raises a transfer, books the goods out and puts them on one of our lorries. The receiving branch books them in when they arrive.
In between, our trading system holds the stock in a transit location. It belongs to no branch, so it does not appear in either branch's stock and no branch manager is measured on it. The system expects every transfer to pass through it for a day or two.
At our year end, the auditors asked for a breakdown of a figure in the stock valuation that nobody in finance could explain. It was the transit location, holding a hundred and eighty six thousand pounds of stock on about fourteen hundred transfer lines. The oldest had been sent in 2022.
We traced a sample. Most of the goods had arrived. Some were unloaded at the wrong branch and kept. Others were put away without anyone booking the transfer in, often on a Saturday when the goods in clerk was off. Months later those branches counted their shelves and found more stock than the system expected, and the stocktake added it as a gain. So the same goods were counted twice: once in transit, where the sending branch's records had left them, and once on the receiving branch's shelf.
The stock valuation had been overstated for years, by an amount that grew a little every week. Nobody had noticed, because each branch's figures were reasonable, and the only place the error was visible was a location nobody looked at.
Transfers are now booked in by scanning the pallet label on arrival, as supplier deliveries already are. Any transfer not received within three working days appears on the exception lists of both branches, and the transit balance by age goes to finance every month. We wrote off what we could not trace and reversed the matching stocktake gains.
Data that sits between two owners belongs to neither unless someone is made responsible for it. Give every in between state an owner and an age limit.
– Serguey Shinder
