The technology industry is racing to build artificial intelligence that can reason, communicate and increasingly behave in ways that seem human.
But there is an obvious paradox in that ambition: science still does not fully understand the extraordinary mind we are trying to reproduce.
In 2016, __an editorial in the academic journal *History of the Human Sciences *__presented the problem in stark terms: despite incredible advances in fields such as molecular biology, evolutionary psychology, artificial intelligence and cognitive neuroscience, one central category continued to resist definition: “the human.”
The importance of that problem had been expressed more directly decades earlier by psychologist
That question has become even more relevant as AI systems have grown more capable. What exactly are the characteristics that distinguish human intelligence? How did consciousness emerge? And how did our remarkable cognitive abilities develop alongside insecurity, aggression, cooperation, creativity and psychological conflict?
These questions form part of the much older scientific and intellectual problem of understanding the human condition.
The problem of consciousness
Nearly four centuries ago,
“So serious are the doubts into which I have been thrown…that I can neither put them out of my mind nor see any way of resolving them. It feels as if I have fallen unexpectedly into a deep whirlpool…”.
Almost four centuries later, consciousness remains one of the most difficult pieces of the puzzle.
But consciousness is not only a question of subjective experience. It also gave humans an extraordinary capacity to understand the relationship between events, anticipate outcomes and increasingly manage behaviour on the basis of that understanding.
There is also an evolutionary puzzle. If the ability to understand cause and effect and consciously adjust behaviour provides such an advantage, why did anything approaching full human consciousness emerge so rarely in evolutionary history?
These questions are approached from different directions by philosophy, neuroscience and evolutionary biology. Together they illustrate how much remains unresolved about the mind that AI increasingly seeks to emulate.
They also raise another question about the human condition: what psychological consequences followed when humans acquired this extraordinary capacity for conscious self-management?
What happened when humans became conscious?
Griffith places the
Natural selection can provide a species with inherited instinctive orientations, while a conscious mind develops understanding by experimenting with cause and effect. Griffith proposes that as our distant hominin ancestors became sufficiently conscious to manage life through understanding, their experiments inevitably began departing from established instinctive orientations. The instincts inevitably resisted those departures, and that orientating ‘pressure’ amounted, in effect, to criticism of an emerging intellect that could not yet explain why its experiments were necessary.
Griffith argues that the
This also gives the hypothesis a further implication. If the insecurity arose because the conscious intellect could not explain why it had to depart from instinct, Griffith argues that gaining that understanding would resolve the original conflict. On his account, anger, egocentricity and alienation are therefore not immutable features of human nature, but defensive responses that can become redundant once their underlying cause is understood.
To advance research, discussion and public understanding of the human condition Griffith established the
Other ways of explaining consciousness
Chalmers, Dehaene and Griffith are therefore asking different questions and proposing fundamentally different explanations. Chalmers focuses on why subjective experience exists, Griffith on the evolutionary and psychological consequences of consciousness emerging in humans, and Dehaene on the neural mechanisms associated with conscious access.
Together they illustrate a larger point: understanding consciousness remains a substantial scientific and philosophical frontier.
AI is making an old question newly urgent
For AI developers, the immediate challenge is not necessarily to solve the human condition. Today’s systems can reproduce remarkable aspects of human language and reasoning without requiring science to possess a complete theory of human nature.
But the closer the ambition moves toward genuinely human-like intelligence, the more difficult the unanswered questions become to ignore.
What distinguishes intelligence from consciousness? How did human consciousness arise? Why are emotion, insecurity, morality, cooperation and conflict so deeply entangled with human cognition? And which of these characteristics, if any, would accompany a genuinely conscious artificial intelligence?
There is no agreed scientific answer.
What there is instead is a continuing endeavour across neuroscience, evolutionary biology, psychology, philosophy and now artificial intelligence to understand the mind that makes us human.
This story was distributed as a release by Jon Stojan under HackerNoon’s Business Blogging Program
