This week Carnegie Mellon opened its computer science classroom to everyone. The new CS Learn page puts it simply: "Free lectures now on YouTube. Free courseware coming next." Machine Learning with Large Datasets, Principles of Computing, Machine Learning Systems, AI Agents, Software Architecture. Real courses from one of the best CS schools on Earth, premiering one after another through November.

On Hacker News the announcement passed 1,600 points within a day. I understand the excitement. When I was learning Android in 2022 through a scholarship programme, a free course was the difference between learning and not learning.

Then I did a small calculation that I want every university putting lectures online to see.

The arithmetic

A typical semester course has around 40 hours of lectures. Streaming YouTube at 480p, a quality where you can still read the code on the slides, uses very roughly 360 to 560 MB an hour, according to carrier guides that measured it. Call it 15 to 20 GB for one course.

Now look at what data costs. The ITU found that in 2024, a basic 2 GB mobile plan in Sub-Saharan Africa cost about 3.9% of average monthly income. That is an average. For the poorest people, and for students, it is far higher.

Put those two numbers together, roughly and honestly: watching one free course on mobile data could cost a student in Kampala, Khartoum or Lagos a third of an average month's income, or more. The lecture is free. Watching it is not.

I don't write this to complain about Carnegie Mellon. They did something generous, and it will change lives. I write it because "free online" has a hidden assumption built in: that the learner sits on cheap, fast, unlimited broadband. Most of the world's learners don't.

Where learners actually are

Many people who start learning to code in Africa today start on an Android phone, not a laptop. They study in bursts, when there is power and when there is a bundle. They share devices. Many download at night when data is cheaper, or at a café with Wi-Fi, and watch later.

For that learner, a 90-minute video is a heavy object. A transcript is light. Slides are light. An audio track is light. Code in a repository is light.

When I built my shop app, Rafu, I designed it to work fully offline, because that is how small shops actually live. Education platforms could learn the same lesson. Offline is not a fallback. For hundreds of millions of people, it is the main road.

What would make free lectures reach everyone

None of this is expensive for a university that already records its lectures.

Publish the transcript next to every video. YouTube already generates captions. A cleaned text version is a few megabytes for a whole course, searchable, translatable, and readable on any phone.

Offer the slides and code as downloads. Many students learn more from the slides and a working example than from the full recording.

Add an audio-only version. A lecture in audio is roughly a tenth of the data of the video, and it can be listened to on a bus.

Make low-resolution and offline viewing easy. A clear note telling learners which videos still work at 360p would save many people a lot of money.

Partner with places that already have bandwidth. Universities, libraries and community hubs in Africa could mirror the course files locally, so students download them once on campus Wi-Fi instead of streaming them on paid bundles.

And then the harder part

Even with the files in hand, many people who start a free course never finish it. The material is rarely what stops them. Being alone is.

Free lectures need people around them: a study group, a mentor, someone who asks on Thursday how far you got. That is why we built developer clubs inside Ishraqa Daily, where learners build real open-source projects with mentors instead of watching alone. A good lecture is the start of learning. The finishing happens in a group.

If you are about to start one of these courses, here is the advice I would give a friend: download the slides first, watch the lectures that matter most, and learn the rest together.

The doors of the classroom are open now. The next step is making sure the road to the door doesn't cost a month's income.

Saifuddin Ahmed is the founder of Ishraqa Daily, a learning platform on Google Play, the App Store and the Microsoft Store, where people learn programming in mentored developer clubs, study languages, read and listen together, and find scholarships and competitions. He also built Rafu and founded OtwoX Digital Solutions. More at saifuddin.dev and LinkedIn.

Drafted with help from an AI writing assistant. The arithmetic is rough on purpose; check your own bundle prices.