A QR code is just data. You can't tell by looking at one whether it holds your URL or somebody else's short link, and that difference decides whether a printed code keeps working.
So we tested it. We opened 20 popular "free QR code generator" sites in a clean headless browser, made a code for a test URL on each one, downloaded the image and decoded it. Here's how, and what came back.
Disclosure: we build EndureQR, a QR code tool, so we have a stake in this. That's why the method is published in full below, and it's easy to repeat.
The question
When you make a QR code for a website link with a generator's default free flow, does the image contain:
- your URL (a static code: it works as long as your page exists), or
- the vendor's short link (a dynamic code: every scan goes through their server, and it stops when they switch the link off)?
The setup
- Playwright with its bundled headless Chromium, a fresh profile per site: no cookies, no login.
- Each site left on its default settings.
- Test URL:
https://example.com/study-<site>, so every payload is traceable. - We never entered an email address, never created an account, and stopped at any sign-up wall.
Decoding the downloads
Downloaded codes come in all shapes: PNGs with no margin, rounded "dot" modules, gradients. jsQR wants clean RGBA pixels, so we ran each image through sharp and tried a few variants until one decoded:
import sharp from "sharp"; import jsQR from "jsqr"; // sharp may hand back 1 (grey), 3 or 4 channels; jsQR always wants RGBA function toRGBA(data, { width, height, channels }) { const out = new Uint8ClampedArray(width * height * 4); for (let i = 0, j = 0; j < out.length; i += channels, j += 4) { const grey = channels < 3; out[j] = data[i]; out[j + 1] = grey ? data[i] : data[i + 1]; out[j + 2] = grey ? data[i] : data[i + 2]; out[j + 3] = 255; } return out; } export async function decode(file) { const variants = [ (img) => img, // as downloaded (img) => img.extend({ top: 40, bottom: 40, left: 40, right: 40, background: "#fff" }), // add a quiet zone (img) => img.greyscale().threshold(160), // hard black/white (img) => img.greyscale().blur(2.5).threshold(245), // merge "dot" modules ]; for (const width of [null, 400, 800]) { for (const v of variants) { let img = sharp(file, { density: 300 }).flatten({ background: "#fff" }); if (width) img = img.resize({ width, kernel: "nearest" }); const { data, info } = await v(img).raw().toBuffer({ resolveWithObject: true }); const res = jsQR(toRGBA(data, info), info.width, info.height, { inversionAttempts: "attemptBoth" }); if (res?.data) return res.data; } } return null; } Two lessons from this part:
- Add a quiet zone before decoding. Several generators export the code with no margin at all, and jsQR (like phone cameras) struggles without one.
- Blur, then threshold, for dotted designs. Round "dot" modules don't read as squares; a small blur followed by a high threshold joins them back into modules. Only one site needed this.
Following the short links
When a payload was a vendor short link, we checked where it went without following it:
curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{http_code} %{redirect_url}\n" https://qrs.ly/xxxxxxx # 302 https://example.com/study-qrstuff All three short links redirected to our test pages on the day. Whether they keep doing so is up to the vendor.
What came back
| Result | Count | Sites |
|---|---|---|
| Direct: the image held our URL | 6 | QRCode Monkey, Scanova, goQR.me, Hovercode, The QR Code Generator (small watermark), QRCodeChimp (via right-click "Save as") |
| Vendor short link, no account needed | 3 | QRStuff (default works for 7 days), Unitag (100 scans max), ME-QR (ads may show after 10 scans) |
| Account or email required before download | 11 | including QR Code Generator, QRFY, Uniqode, Flowcode, Bitly, Canva, Adobe Express |
Two things surprised us:
- Defaults matter more than features. QRStuff makes a dynamic code by default, and the notice next to its Download button says it "works for 7 days, or 30 days with a free account" (to its credit, it says so clearly and offers a Static switch). QR Code Generator has "Scan tracking" on by default, which puts the download behind a sign-up; switch it off and you get a direct code with no account.
- Previews aren't proof. Several sign-up sites show a code on the page that decodes to your URL. That's a preview, not necessarily the file a registered user gets, so we didn't count any of them as direct.
The full table, with each company's own words on what happens when a trial or plan ends (10 of the 17 services offering dynamic codes say some codes stop, pause or change), is here: We made a free QR code on 20 generators.
Check a code yourself in 30 seconds
You don't need any of the code above to check one QR code. Point your phone camera at it and read the address it shows before tapping. If it's your own domain, it's direct. If it's a short domain you don't own, the code depends on that company.
If you build QR features into an app, the takeaway is simple: for anything printed, encode the destination directly unless you really need editing or analytics, and if you do use a redirect, make sure you control it.
Limits
One run per site, one desktop browser, one location, on 21 November 2026. Sites change and A/B test their defaults, so treat these results as a snapshot. We couldn't see what registered users get on the 11 sign-up sites.
