Free is a claim about money. It is silent about everything else.

A photo scavenger hunt costs the player no money at all, and that is true. But it also costs them a phone battery, a few megabytes of data, a walk they would not otherwise have taken, and - this is the part that gets forgotten - it puts other people's faces into their camera without asking them.

None of that makes the app bad. It does mean the terms have to be honest about what is being exchanged, and that is a design problem rather than a legal one.

The costs nobody puts on the label

Data. A city hunt needs a map, some imagery and a check against a reference picture. That is real network traffic on somebody else's plan, often abroad.

Attention. This is the largest cost and the hardest to price. A player spends twenty minutes looking at a street instead of at a screen, which is the point, but it is still twenty minutes.

Other people. A player photographing a busy square will catch strangers. Blurring faces is a default we should be able to explain in one sentence, not three paragraphs of legal.

Battery. A hunt that runs for an hour with the camera open will flatten a phone. People plan around that.

What a terms page should actually answer

The point of terms is not to protect the company. It is to tell the user, before they are invested, the four things they would be annoyed to discover later.

What happens to the photographs they take. Whether anything is kept after the check. What happens if they want everything deleted. And what they agree to by using the thing at all.

If a reader has to email to find out whether their photographs are kept, the terms have failed, whatever they say.

Short beats thorough

Our own terms are short, because the questions they need to answer are few and the answers are not complicated. They are here, in plain sentences, on their own page rather than folded into a privacy policy: pinghunt.com/terms.

The privacy side - what is collected and what happens to it - is on its own page too: pinghunt.com/privacy-policy.

The uncomfortable part

The honest version of "free" is: you give us a little of your time, a little of your data and a little of your attention, and we give you a walk around a city you did not know.

That is a good trade. It is also a trade, and it should be written down as one rather than dressed up as a gift.

The rest of the design is written up here, with screenshots: pinghunt.com/docs.

The general principle, if you are building something free that asks for people's attention: list the costs the user is actually paying, and make sure the terms page answers them in plain language. If the terms page is the only place a fact appears, it is not really true.