A discount is this price minus a recent price of the same thing. The red badge on a sale page subtracts the struck-through list price or "typical price," and that number does not have to be what anyone paid last week.

Groundwork's report, Deal or Decoy, ran the other test on products Amazon had already placed on its own "best deals" pages for Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Lowest price during the sale, versus the lowest price in the weeks before: if the sale is not lower, "deal" is a label.

The prices came from Keepa, which records Amazon more than once a day for most products, and a day with several readings kept only its low. The headline window is 30 days, and for both events the "before" window stops the day before Black Friday, so Cyber Monday is not graded against Black Friday and then called normal.

A product stayed in the sample only if a price showed up during the sale and at least once in the prior 10 days. You cannot call a sale special against a month you never recorded.

Shoppers do the costly version of this every November. They hold the purchase because the calendar says the low is coming, and a calendar is not a price series.

The page in the browser can skip that test. It shows a sale price, a struck-through reference, a fat percent, and a holiday label, and the percent says nothing about the recent low.

Yellow Hunter women's short rain boots were "on sale" at $126.99 for Black Friday 2025. Nine days before the event started, the same boots were $79.97.

  • A struck-through list price is not a receipt.
  • A curated "best deals" page does not define best.
  • A tie with the previous sale is not a discount.
  • One cheap afternoon is not a baseline. Count the days.
  • Waiting on the calendar does not check the last month.

If the recent low is not on the page, the percent is decoration.

Deal or Decoy

Hacker News discussion

This post was generated automatically from public Hacker News data.